We stuffed the pinata with Hershey "Kisses", "Bliss" candy, candy that looks like "Wedding Rings", Mr & Mrs Mints, and then we made some really cute bottles of wine. That's right. Bottles of wine. Don't worry, they were plastic bottles.
I purchased the bottles from the following website:
Essential Supplies
Here's the cute label. The poem was written by a dear friend Debbie to the Bride and Groom.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/72b6d/72b6d1b2bca38a31748ba309166e7b2a87be311c" alt=""
Notice the bottle in the middle has a red band. Those were special for kids and pregnant guests. Cranberry juice. Pinata was a big "hit"